It may but happen, in the revolutions of time, that some one of the vast majority of your committee may be subjected to an unjust and false accusation, which should be submitted to the judgment of twelve men within the jury-box or of 1 man on the bench; twelve men recent from the individuals and warmed with the instinctive sympathies of humanity, or one man, separated from the folks by his station and by the habits of a life passed in seclusion and study. A jury-trial must be the identical whether a man or lady be arraigned. The difficulty was began by a sailor often known as Kanaka Pete, who lived within the What Cheer House, over a girl known as Iodoform Kate. It’s fashionable, we know, just now to heap contumely upon girls who demand to be allowed to get pleasure from their civil political rights. The judge stated, “That can not be allowed. Gentlemen of the jury, you’re discharged;” and the jurors left the field. The judge then instructed the clerk to take the verdict, and the clerk mentioned, “Gentlemen of the jury, hearken to your verdict as the court docket hath recorded it. You say you discover the defendant responsible of the offense charged; so say you all.” No response whatever was made by the jury, both by word or signal.
Your petitioner respectfully submits that, in these proceedings, she has been denied the rights guaranteed by the Constitution to all persons accused of crime, the suitable of trial by jury, and the precise to have the help of counsel for their protection. It is a mockery to call her trial a trial by jury; and except the help of counsel could also be restricted to the argument of legal questions, with out the privilege of saying a word to the jury upon the question of the guilt or innocence in fact of the celebration charged, or the privilege of ascertaining from the jury whether they do or do not comply with the verdict pronounced by the courtroom in their identify, she has been denied the assistance of counsel for her protection. It’s the practice in civil causes for the court docket, if there is no battle within the evidence, to direct a verdict for the plaintiff or for the defendant, because in such case the court docket might put aside a verdict and grant a brand new trial in favor of plaintiff or defendant.
The vast majority of the Committee have determined that inasmuch as the relief prayed for by the memorial can not be granted, the Committee will ask to be discharged from its further consideration, and is not going to categorical any opinion as to the correctness or incorrectness of the course pursued on the trial of Miss Anthony. However the denial of her rights to miss Susan B. Anthony in a court docket of the Union is thought to be unworthy the attention of the American Senate. And the topic underneath consideration is necessary even to men who are whatever the rights of women. While fully agreeing that the deliverance of girls from early prejudices and unnatural trammels was a necessity which the development of culture and the altered conditions of industrial relations have been bound to result in in time, they had been “convinced that the pursuit of a mere outward equality with men is for ladies not only vain however demoralizing,” and that it led to “a whole false impression of woman’s true dignity and special mission.” It was pointed out that the query was pre-eminently one for the center lessons to determine. We have now acted upon the doctrines of the Declaration of Independence, as far as to make all males equal before the law; but girls, our mothers, our wives, our sisters, and our daughters, we condemn to inequality-many to servitude.
To those who are indifferent whether or not a lady be deprived of or be permitted to take pleasure in even the rights which are secured to her by the Constitution, it may be urged that a foul precedent set within the trial of a girl who has presumed to precise her choice as to those that should make legal guidelines for her, laws by which her rights are to be affected and her property be taxed, may stand in the way in which of some man’s rights hereafter. Determined to ignore the established rules and rules, he decided to get pleasure from himself in his own sweet manner — disrupting the courses when he bothered to attend, and drinking with new associates corresponding to Geoff Mohammed and Tony Carricker, when he chose to go absent. Summer Hoyland talks to Tony in regards to the corruption story and Tony tells her he was simply winding Dane up. The House of Lords in England or the Senate of the United States may interact in any investigation looking to legislation, although, as an incident to, or a result of, such investigation, it might seem that some officer who’s impeachable has been responsible of conduct for which he could be impeached. Then, absolutely, in a case like this, where there is neither suggestion nor suspicion of corrupt conduct on the part of the estimable judge before whom the trial was conducted, it can’t be improper for a committee of the Senate to inquire whether, within the trial of a citizen for alleged violation of the laws of the United States, a precedent dangerous to the liberties of every citizen has been set.